back to top
Politics

Here's Bill Clinton's Personnel File From His Time As An Arkansas College Professor

A performance review of Clinton’s class says he relied “on an unstructured approach.”

Posted on

In 1973, Bill Clinton was nearing the end of his time as a student at Yale Law School. He had already graduated from Georgetown and attended Oxford on a Rhodes Scholarship.

The next step in Clinton's life, one which would pave the way for his entry into politics, was a return to his home state of Arkansas.

Clinton's somewhat embellished the story of his return for years, as revealed by David Maraniss in his 1995 biography of Clinton, First in His Class.

Clinton would say that his return to his home state as an assistant professor at the University of Arkansas School of Law was " a pure accident" (although Clinton's telling of the tale in his auto-biography My Life would be somewhat more true to what actually happened).

As Clinton would say, he was driving home from Connecticut at the end of his tenure at Yale, and at the advice of a professor, called the dean of the Arkansas Law School and was able to talk his way into a job interview in a spur of the moment event.

The truth, as Maraniss found, was that Clinton lobbied for the job months before he graduated through a politically-connected friend in Arkansas who served as a state legislator and knew an associate dean at the law school.

The dean of the law school, Wylie H. Davis, told Maraniss for his book that Clinton's telling was "amusingly inaccurate and somewhat melodramatic."

Clinton's hiring was fairly routine, Davis said, and Clinton's glowing resume, great letters of recommendation, and a meeting in which he impressed the school's faculty appointments committee were what would eventually lead to his hiring at the law school.

Documents related to Clinton's hiring and time at the school were obtained by BuzzFeed News through an open records request with the University of Arkansas.

Clinton's personnel file from the school details his hiring and time as a professor, including reviews of his performance from faculty, several handwritten notes, and letters to request leave for his early runs for office.

The highlights and the full file are below:

Advertisement
Advertisement

The file contains several letters of recommendation for Clinton's application to the job. Clinton cites the letters in his autobiography, My Life, as helping him land the job, though the contents of the actual letters haven't been seen before.

A letter of recommendation for the job from Yale professor and former Assistant Attorney General Burke Marshall: "He has an attractive personality, and would perform well in a classroom, with patience and tolerance for his students."

A letter of recommendation from Yale law professor Steven Duke: "There is no doubt in my mind that Bill Clinton is one of our brightest recent graduates. He is quick, imaginative, speculative, and pragmatic."

Advertisement

A letter of recommendation from Yale professor Marvin A. Chirelstein: "He is clear-headed and tough-minded but at the same time imaginative and speculative in his approach to difficult problems."

A letter of recommendation from John Baker, the first black professor at Yale Law School: "It is probably most apparent to you that Bill's academic record is not outstanding...however, I do not think that his record reflects in anyway his true ability."

A recommendation letter from Caroline A. Dinegar, the University of New Haven political science chair where Clinton taught for two years: "I found Mr. Clinton a delightful personality and totally dependable faculty member."

Advertisement

Here's the full file:

Andrew Kaczynski is a political reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in New York.

Contact Andrew Kaczynski at andrew.kaczynski@buzzfeed.com.

Megan Apper is a political reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in New York.

Contact Megan Apper at megan.apper@buzzfeed.com.

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.