Skip To Content

    "Friends" Fans Just Spotted A Continuity Error In The Show

    Who is that guy???

    It's been 27 years since Friends premiered, and yet...we're still out here discovering continuity errors on the show!

    The Friends cast walk down a NYC street dressed in formal wear
    Warner Bros. Television / Getty Images

    Just this week, a Friends fan on TikTok uncovered a new error from Episode 8 of Season 18, "The One in Massapequa." In the episode, Ross and Monica's parents, Jack and Judy Geller, are throwing a party to celebrate their 35th wedding anniversary. The whole gang attends, including a very pregnant Rachel.


    Who is THAT? #friendstok #tvbloopers #tvblooperfound #whoknew #trending #viral #fyp #foryou #xyzcba

    ♬ There goes the crackhead - Matthew Daniel Gordon

    In the clip shown on TikTok, one moment Jack is in the scene, and the next thing you know, it's a random man standing next to Ross!

    @bronniiieee / Via

    WHO IS HE??

    Eugene is replaced by a random actor and the text says Who are you
    @bronniiieee / Via

    It turns out that Jack (and the actor who played him, Elliott Gould) didn't pull a disappearing act; instead, it all has to do with the way the show was filmed.

    Friends / Via

    According to Digital Spy and some camera-savvy TikTokers, the error is noticeable because it's from the HD remastered version of the episode, which has a 16:9 aspect ratio. The show was originally shot in the 4:3 format, meaning that the wider aspect ratio is going to show a lot more than was originally intended — like stand-in actors who don't quite fit in.

    Friends/Giphy / Via

    Checks out!

    It turns out, this isn't even the first time fans have noticed an error like this! There have been several instances when stand-ins were spotted instead of the actual actors, like this one:

    You can't fool a #Friends fanatic. Why is this not-Rachel standing in for Rachel in this ep?

    @decider / Via Twitter: @decider

    While those errors can seemingly be explained, there's another error from "The One in Massapequa" that has me scratching my head...

    Friends/Giphy / Via

    WHY are Jack and Judy wearing the SAME EXACT outfits at their party as in their anniversary photo on the wall?? Did they take the photo and then run to Kinkos in the middle of the party?

    Jack and Judy Gellar chat with their guest while the photo can be seen in the background
    @bronniiieee / Via

    Seems a little suspicious, if you ask me...but alas, only one mystery can be solved today.


    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form