We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
Hey! While we’re doing our best to make sure the products we feature will arrive in time for Christmas, shipping times are especially tricky this year and can vary depending on where you live, which product you purchase, and more. Shop early and be sure to double check the retailers’ websites for shipping information to ensure that your gift will arrive in time for the 25th!
1. A poster with inspirational quotes from a variety of musicals because the best life lessons are sung, not spoken.
2. Musicals: The Definitive Illustrated Story, a coffee table book packed with all the information they've ever wanted to know about musicals throughout history.
3. An "Ohmygod you guys" throw pillow for the ~serious~ fan who knows this will make their living room ~so much better~ (and also probably make them break out into song).
4. A is for Audra, a children's book about Broadway's leading ladies (from A to Z) to help teach the next generation about all the star power that has graced the stage and made it what it is today.
5. A Mrs. Lovett's famous pie shoppe cutting board you *might* not want to show to any guests who come over because they'll be apt to avoid any food you serve...
6. A theater-themed Cards Against Humanity expansion pack they say is Lin Manuel-Miranda's favorite (and when has Lin ever steered us wrong?).
7. A gift subscription to the Broadway Wine Club your friend will be on cloud ~wine~ when they receive, because not only will they get a shipment of wine every three months, but they'll also get access to exclusive events with Broadway stars, meaning they can bring Broadway into their own home (without paying a ridiculous amount for one cup of wine).
8. A shadowbox to store all the ticket stubs they've been collecting. They will look so much cuter on their wall than in a pile!
9. A "Merde" bag made from curtains from actual Broadway shows, so you're essentially giving a piece of Broadway history for them to keep (and treasure) forever.
10. A set of Come From Away-themed coloring postcards, because when your friend takes a ~Gander~ at them, \they'll be so excited that they get to spend some time decompressing and coloring in designs from a musical with one of the biggest hearts.
11. And a set of 12 Broadway colored pencils to go with the coloring pages to help them ~seize the grey~ and transform the postcards (or anything else really) into a work of art.
12. An illustrated poster to show everyone that they've been a true Broadway fan long before Hamilton came on the scene.
13. Sugar, Butter, Flour: The Waitress Pie Cookbook, a book they'll be ~opening up~ all the time because they know ~what's inside~ is going to show them exactly ~what baking can do~ (i.e. make delicious pies at home).
14. A Falsettos "I'm Breaking Down" enamel pin showcasing any theatergoer's mood when they listen to their favorite cast album *again* and relive all the highs and lows for the 4958th time.
15. A pair of Hamil-toes socks they'll wear ~nonstop~ to show their love and appreciation for the $10 founding father.
16. A gift card for PlusPass on Broadway Plus, a service that gives the giftee access to virtual group events with some of their favorite Broadway stars. This means they could be in the (Zoom) room where it happens and take a Hamilton dance class or even be part of a Q&A with Evan Hansen. How cool is that?!?
17. A Be A Broadway Star board game where you compete to be the biggest broadway star (as if they haven't been doing that already).
18. An illustrated map of the NYC Theater District to remind them of where all the magic happens in the best area of NYC (minus Times Square, of course).
19. A Broadway vinyl wall decal that'll turn any area of their home into the Great White Way, especially when they start blasting all their favorite cast albums.
20. A tank top with the names of all the leading ladies that matter in their world. Now, imagine if they were all in a room together. *faints immediately*
21. A tote bag absolutely covered in logos from some of the best musicals ever on it so they can be loud and proud about their love for all things musical theater.
22. A Phantom of the Opera mask wall clock to make sure they don't stay home past the ~point of no return~ to get where they need to be on time. If only it played the overture right before they have to leave to really kick them into gear...
23. A Strong Female lead T-shirt with an important message about who they are as a person, even if they haven't gotten their chance to shine...yet.
24. A pair of their own kinky boots to help them strut their stuff and ~take them higher~ than they've ever been before.
25. A musical history subway map acrylic tray that celebrates collaborations in the history of musicals and will be a conversation starter with any other theater fan.
26. Home Work: A Memoir of My Hollywood Years, a book by the one-and-only Julie Andrews, in which she talks about everything from Mary Poppins, The Sound of Music, and even Victor/Victoria. We do not deserve this queen.
27. A The Last Five Years timeline poster that shows the progression of Jamie and Cathy's relationship in linear order I'm crying just looking at.
28. A pair of Hadestown carnation earrings for a subtle reminder they can wear to help remind themselves that ~we take what they can get, and we make the most of it~.
29. A 525,600 minutes bangle that's not only the number of minutes in a year but also approximately how many times they've watched Rent.
30. A frame designed specifically to fit their favorite Playbill and ticket so they can show the world what show has meant the most to them (or humblebrag that they got to see Hamilton with the original cast – UGH).
31. The Broadway Musical Quiz Book, which is filled with almost 80 quizzes that may stump even the most die-hard fan. But if musicals have taught us anything, we're up for the challenge, right?
32. A Don't Lose Your Head sweatshirt they may *actually* lose their head over (or just freak out and say OMGOMGOMG) because it'll be a ~10 amongst these threes~ (a.k.a. all their other gifts).
33. A vanity mirror to make their room feel like a backstage dressing area and them feel like a huge star. They may get confused when nobody is waiting for them at the "stage door" when they leave their house (how rude!).
34. A beautiful sterling silver butterfly necklace inspired by your favorite young Donna. Let's hope it brings you as much luck as it brought her (and her three baby daddies)...
35. Too Much Is Not Enough: A Memoir of Fumbling Toward Adulthood, a book by Andrew Rannells because their favorite Elder Price-turned-TV star has stories to tell about his journey to the stage, and we can't wait to read them.
36. A You Will Be Found motivational mug that'll help them remember ~you are not alone~ in this world and coffee will always support them no matter what.
37. A "Not throwing Away My Shot" tri-layer necklace for a simple every day reminder that they're ~young scrappy and hungry~ and can always ~get the job done~.
38. A gift subscription to BroadwayHD because, yeah, other streaming services are great, but true fans will obsess over having a place where they can always go and put on a great musical such as, Kinky Boots, Sound of Music, or even The Phantom of The Opera.
39. A truly epic Wicked-themed charm bracelet for the musical that has changed them ~for good~ and still makes them sob uncontrollably every time they see Elphaba fly.
40. The Prom character art print to showcase some of the favorite characters on their wall and also remember that's ~life's no dress rehearsal~.
41. Broadway Sheet Music Collection: 2010-2017, a book in which they can use to learn how to actually bring some of their favorite songs to life instead of just continuing to belt them in the shower.
42. A Laura Geller 31 baked eyeshadow palette part of Beauty on Broadway, so 15% off net proceeds will go to support Broadway through its intermission right now. So not only will they get a super sweet eye palette to use to create whatever character look they want, but it's also a gift that gives back.
43. A 2,000-piece The Great White Way puzzle that really should only be put together while listening to a Broadway playlist, of course.
44. And a "Young Scrappy and Hungry" onesie to inspire the next generation of theater lovers, because you know one day they're going to ~blow us all away~.
Your friend when they open this super sweet gift from you:
Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides
