1. Ali has a twin sister.
2. And her twin sister is Bethany Young.
3. And Ali is actually not Ali, she’s Bethany…
4. And Ezra impregnated Alison.
Say goodbye to #ezria if this theory is true.
5. AND IS THAT SPENCER? OMG.
6. But the Aria theories hurt the most.
7. Here’s a hint:
8. Another hint here:
That was definitely not a mistake.
9. So now Aria and Bethany are related?
WHAT IS HAPPENING
I NEED THE ANSWERS.
10. The Big A clue.
THIS THEORY IS BREAKING MY HEART.
11. Mrs. D was responsible for Ali’s death…
Are you confused yet? Because I am.
12. Mrs. D *Was. Protecting CECE DRAKE. R.I.P.
13. Toby and Bethany are twins. Or Bethany is Ali’s twin. Or Bethany is related to Aria somehow. Someone is definitely related to Bethany.
My head is spinning.
14. If Bethany is Toby’s twin, this tattoo is actually for her and not Jenna.
Are you following?
15. And then there are these mind-blowing theories that would actually spin my head so hard that it would literally fly off. Literally.
16. It was all a dream.
Every fans reaction:
17. The torture never ends.
Marlene, you can’t keep doing this to us.
18. If this plot twist came true I wouldn’t know whether to slow clap or sob.
But take heart…
You right now:
You for the next 17 seasons:
And finally a PSA message for all you theorizers.