So let me clear this up. In the show, he definitely attacked her, and I assume that he was about to rape her as in the books. I wasn’t trying to bring up the books BECAUSE I knew people would whine about it. And yes, the show and book are clearly different. The show has sucked since season 3. The books have/do not. And I didn’t bring Erik Northman into it; you did. As for Erik, I have much more respect for him because of the books, and less for Bill for the same reason. I’m trying to make a clear argument based on the show alone, but since you wanted to bring up the books, there you go.