I agree with you but I don’t the law doesn’t provide the wiggle room to argue that. Unless they can prove they broke up when she turned 18, I don’t have much hope for Kate. Personally, I think the state should consider this law on a case-by-case basis, or that students who meet in high school should be exempt. Side note, I misread the arrest record. She was arrested on 2-16-2013(February) not 12-16-2012(December). So it was 6 full months after she turned 18.