Oh hey, this version doesn’t burn my ears! Thumbs up.

As soon as I heard her perform ‘I need a Doctor’ on the grammys, I became OBSESSED. Google ‘Holly Brook’ to hear some of her other stuff.

same difference

I’ll have to say this one is better because I hate Scree-anna’s “singing”. Skylar is sooo much better.

I love this.

And I read on wikipedia that she’s the girl that sings in “Where’d You Go” by Fort Minor but she went under the name Holly Brook. Weird…

Love it! I’m not saying this in a bad way and she sounds great, but doesn’t her voice sound a bit like Bieber?

This is just like the first time I heard Dido’s “Thank You.”

It’s pretty, but it’s too slow for my tastes.. nothing wrong with it, at all. Just way too slow for my liking..

The song has an incredibly strong chorus, which is what really makes both versions. I don’t think this has to be an either/or thing. It works both ways.

better! her voice is haunting and beautiful!

so much better.

So much better.

So much better, now mash this with Em’s rap, and we got a better hit.

I’d say they’re equal and only because Eminems’ part is just as passionate.

Better, only because I don’t really like Rihanna’s songs. Also, I like how no one minds how Eminem/Rihanna not only sampled this song, but actually covered it and changed it a bit, but when Kanye does it, it’s “hate hate hate”.

amazing. i wouldnt say better because they both are are equally good in there own way

Right on, Holly Brook!

better!