Broadway's Carole King Played A Game Of "Jessie Mueller Or Carole King?"

The Broadway star plays Carole King in Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, and now she reveals which leading lady is more likely to get drunk at brunch.

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

This year, Jessie Mueller won the Tony award for Best Lead Actress in a Musical for her depiction of Carole King in Beautiful: The Carole King Musical. The two talented ladies even performed at the Tonys together.

Jessie stopped by the BuzzFeed NYC office to serenade us and play a little game called "Carole or Jessie," in which she decides who's more likely to forget song lyrics on stage or eat an entire pizza. Here's what happened.

Archive Photos / Mike Coppola / Getty

Belt out a Celine Dion song at karaoke?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"ME. No hesitation."

Get stage fright?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"A young Carole, maybe."

Sing in the shower?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"I guess me, it would be weird if I knew Carole's showering habits."

Swoon over Hugh Jackman?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"Oh my."

Eat an entire pizza?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"I know I certainly would."

Binge-watch a show on Netflix?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"I have done this."

Get drunk at brunch?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"Ahh, let's say Carole for this one, maybe she'd have a bloody mary."

Trip on the red carpet at an awards show?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"Absolutely me."

Get their acceptance speech cut off by the music at an awards show?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"No one would dare do that to Carole now, she's too big!"

Pull a prank backstage?

"Maybe Carole would."

Run for political office?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"She should, and I hope she does."

Forget song lyrics on stage?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"I have done this. I think I just sang the same verse twice."

Star in a reality TV show?

David J. Bertozzi / BuzzFeed

"Neither of us!"