I'm thinking a lot of these boys are on here based MORE on the music. Andrew definitely gets top spot, both music and looks. I personally understand Drew, Caws, Gibbard, and Monks being on the list, but mainly because of their correlative sound and writing. But, honestly, based on both looks and music ability, I believe Oberst should be a little higher on the list. And, lchen12345, I agree, where's Sufjan??  K, I'm done being an indie snob.
Nice list!