Menstruation Photography Shouldn’t Be Shocking
Vice magazine published a gallery of photos of women menstruating through their clothes. Well, so what?
Brace yourself, this is gonna get messy. Prepare to be disgusted. Or titillated if that’s what rocks your boat. At least, those are the reactions Vice is probably hoping you’ll have when you click on their “There Will Be Blood” post — a gallery of photos of women menstruating.
I’m woman enough to admit it. They got me. A friend sent me the link and we had a moment of outrage and giggling and disgust and moved on. But my brain didn’t. It percolated over those images with niggling sense that I was being hoodwinked. And finally, like the veritable light bulb moment, it hit me. There’s nothing wrong or gross with any of those photos.
Nothing particularly scandalous going on in this gallery other than obvious taboo. No nudity, no inference of sex save one photo. There is nothing here that couldn’t happen (or has happened) to half the world’s population. So I propose an alternate hypothesis: These photos are beautiful. Or at least a conversation starter as why our culture still sees menstruation as something gross and dirty instead of just another part of life.
So bring it on, menstruation photography. I refuse to be cowed into thinking my body’s natural functions are nothing more than fodder for shock value puns.
HOT ON
- noodlermonsterr Menstruation Photography... and thinks it’s Win
- giantsockmonkey thinks Menstruation Photography... is WTF
-
Dariana a year agoThere’s actually quite a bit of research out there on ‘disgust’—and not necessarily the psychological or physiological function of it, but why we, philosophically, feel disgusted by images like this one, despite our knowledge of it being a ‘natural’ process. Here are some things I’ve read over time:
1) It *is* a physiological defence mechanism to protect our bodies from contracting disease (if we didn’t feel disgusted by defecation, we would, um, touch it more).
2) It is the ‘between’ state of life and death. We are neither disgusted by a newborn baby nor a corpse, but a ROTTING corpse disgusts us because it is in the process of total death. Excrement likewise disgusts because a live object is expelling a ‘dead’ thing (and frequently, as with faeces, they come from having eaten dead creatures).
3) Disgust is a tool to limit our generally unlimited and insatiable desires. So whilst, yes, we should embrace this opportunity to discuss our disgust—if you will—we shouldn’t feel that we must NOT be disgusted by it, nor should we feel we MUST be disgusted by it. There is more than sexism and gender normativity at play here, but I’m really glad this conversation is brought to light. -
- basli Menstruation Photography... and thinks it’s Win
- suemacdonaldk thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew
- kristenf3 thinks Menstruation Photography... is OMG
- donnav3 thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew & Win
- AshlyWithNoE thinks Menstruation Photography... is Fail, WTF & Ew
- Catherine L. thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew
- kiavag216 thinks Menstruation Photography... is OMG
- idkwhattosay thinks Menstruation Photography... is Win & Ew
- jessm4 thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew, Trashy & WTF
- heathers11 thinks Menstruation Photography... is Fail & Ew
- katyar thinks Menstruation Photography... is Win
- oprahsweave Menstruation Photography... and thinks it’s Win & LOL
- hylar thinks Menstruation Photography... is LOL
- tiffchin thinks Menstruation Photography... is Win
-
- huffingtonpost.com readers just made Menstruation Photography... hotter
- blog.timesunion.com readers just made Menstruation Photography... hotter
- vanessak thinks Menstruation Photography... is OMG, Ew & LOL
- buzzrabbit thinks Menstruation Photography... is LOL
-
kyrski a year agoi feel like even this photo is sensationalized and glamorized. i’m not embarrassed about my period, and shouldn’t be, but the reality is, it’s messy and stains things i like to wear. if this was me, i’d clean myself off and be pissed that i leaked on seemingly expensive gym shorts.
-
-
lynne benoux a year agoI thought it was provocative, but really felt nothing but familiarity. How is anyone (women) squeamish about this? I bet they don’t have sex on their periods either.
-
-
Jennifer O. a year agoI personally think its gross because our society is male dominated and sexist (even you women).
-
- Jennifer O. Menstruation Photography... and thinks it’s Win & Ew
-
Jennifer O. a year agoit’s great art because it makes you ask yourself WHY we have such a violent reaction to these photos. of course they gross you out, but why? would it be the same if you saw a guy peeing on a wall with pee trickling down on the ground? she’s not trying to say “this is not gross”; she’s saying “you think this is gross, why?”
-
- Imahoot thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew
-
zombiebait a year agoIve menstruated for 20 + years, and I still find this gross. Not in a biblically unclean way, but in the way that I don’t want to come in contact with some woman’s menstrual blood in public. And that is what these pics makes me think of… spreading disease.
-
-
- Alissa Mushkin thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew & WTF
- darksilhouettes thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew
- Iris P. Menstruation Photography...
- craigh6 thinks Menstruation Photography... is Trashy
- amberi Menstruation Photography... and thinks it’s Fail
- noodl33333 thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew
- shalalalalauooo thinks Menstruation Photography... is Win
-
-
- Sticky Moments thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew
- Happysquid thinks Menstruation Photography... is WTF
- Museviolet thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew & WTF
- Menstruation Photography... is starting to get hot on Facebook Share It
- skier thinks Menstruation Photography... is Win
- calli441 thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew & WTF
- hwh97 thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew
-
MEGALISA a year agoI’m a chick and I think it’s gross. In fact, I fucking hate my period and got on a particular birth control to make it happen as infrequently as possible. Most people aren’t into the sight of blood and as a previous commenter said, blood from genitals - no thanks. I also guarantee that any chick that’s had a sudden, messy run in with the red tide didn’t think it was beautiful. Nor was the embarrassment or the discarding of a garment because that shit don’t come out.
-
-
Giovanni Lido a year agoAre people so hugely disrespectful of others that they’d post photos of them in such an embarrassing state as this and then post them online? If you get home and notice the blood going down your leg or staining your clothes, you’ve already suffered; but then to see it on somebody’s website? Disgusting: and by “disgusting” I mean what the people with this website are doing. They’re the ones who should be feeling shame right now.
-
- Giovanni Lido thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew & WTF
- proud30lithuanian thinks Menstruation Photography... is WTF
- fixg thinks Menstruation Photography... is Win
- aegyeol Menstruation Photography...
-
-
FlickMontana a year agoIt’s gross. Now, it isn’t black magic or witchcraft or “unclean” in any way other than the literal, but it IS gross. I keep my bodily functions to myself, you do the same, K? It’s a great social standard that’s worked well for a good long time.
-
-
-
- Floobity Menstruation Photography... and thinks it’s Ew
-
- Liz K. thinks Menstruation Photography... is Win
- davehouse1290 thinks Menstruation Photography... is Ew, Fail & WTF











Special Reactions
Your Reaction?
GET STARTED