Men’s Magazine’s “Demeaning” Facebook Image Banned
Zoo Weekly asked its readers to pick which half of this woman they preferred, and why.
The post is no longer on the magazine’s Facebook page.
Just a few of the lovely comments on the post.
The October Facebook post was just censored this week by Australia’s ad watchdog, the Advertising Standards Bureau.
The complaint read, in part:
“The image, disturbing nature of having a disembodied woman and the offensive, clearly sexist and even abusive nature of some responses on a page being used to advertise this product should not be allowed. Both the pictures, the questions that are posed and the responses are regularly demeaning and unacceptable to women. Women are objectified and sexualised.”
Zoo publisher ACP argues, however, that the post is editorial material, not advertising. They added that “(men’s) choice of Zoo magazine is for a purpose — to engage with content that doesn’t require too much thought.”
Looking at their Facebook page, they’ve got that right.
But is a brand’s Facebook page’s content advertising or editorial?
It’s a sticky wicket that’s going to see lots of courtroom action in the coming years.
Via: mumbrella.com.au
HOT ON
Facebook Conversations
40 Responses So Far
- Contributions
- (Page 2 of 2)
-
Swagasaurus Rex 5 months agoI’m most offended by the high school level Photoshop hit job, It’s not really hard to airbrush in a new shadow and make the skin at the “half-cut” look like skin instead of an oval paint swatch with a shitty highlight.
-
-
the BuckWheat 5 months agoThe question at hand is which half of the woman that men would pick and why. The hub-bub seems to be all about the question and nobody cares what people are giving for answers. Seems to me that people are shooting the messenger and covering their ears about the message. Me? I would pick the torso because that is where the head is and the brains and personality of this young woman are more important than anything. This is because the body will age and attractive features will slowly become less so, and things break or fail, but we hope her character and personality only get better with time.
-
-
rebeccas21 5 months agonice try on being all egalitarian but I think maybe some of the hub-bub is over the women being CUT IN HALF
-
- Bhargavi thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy
- rooroo Men's Magazine's "Demean...
- louisl3 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is WTF
- ketchup thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail & Trashy
- marinark Men's Magazine's "Demean... and thinks it’s Trashy
- childeharold thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Cute
- owlsareraptors thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy
-
- allisonc10 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is WTF & Trashy
- hermitina thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is WTF
-
maeby 5 months agoI can’t believe people are arguing that this isn’t sexist. Especially with their prime point being that it’s funny? Are girls actually defending this? You don’t have to defend this crap just to be a chill girl. WTF? The ad was a little sexist, but this is the sort of thing that spurs the culture that gives us the comment section.
Aren’t we over this already? It’s not the 50’s -
- shortfiction thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy, Fail & WTF
- d3g thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail & WTF
-
benn 5 months agoTaken out of context, the image itself isn’t necessarily offensive (it would be interesting to know its original context…), but when you add in the caption / question, the extremely misogynistic / chauvanistic responses (admittedly from a magazine whose very raison d’être is to objectify women) and (crucially) the fact that, being Facebook, the content was publicly accessible; it’s not hard to see why the regulator felt the need to stamp on it.
-
- Kiwi thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is LOL
- ekb thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy & Ew
- Patty Lazatin thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail
- noura thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy
- ginaem24 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy & Fail
- ObsessivePopCultureDisorder thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail & Trashy
- merricartd thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail & Ew
- kirstenl2 Men's Magazine's "Demean... and thinks it’s Trashy, Fail & WTF
- lexizazzleb thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is WTF, Ew & Trashy
- Alejandra V. thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail, Trashy & WTF
- Plus182 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is LOL
-
-
- catherinek4 Men's Magazine's "Demean...
- maggielizer thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Ew
-
- mottmarvink Men's Magazine's "Demean...
- avivah Men's Magazine's "Demean... and thinks it’s Ew
- dc141 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail & Trashy
- EllysaE thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail
- erikarichardd thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Ew, Fail & Trashy
-
- jr77 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Ew & WTF
- Eric Scheidt thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is WTF
-
-
- lovelyDay020891 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail & Trashy
- kaishou thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail & WTF
-
- Shinythings thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy & Fail
- your mom thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Ew & Trashy
- krwhynot thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail
- micaelal thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Fail & Trashy
- sarahw34 Men's Magazine's "Demean... and thinks it’s WTF, Ew & Trashy
- Gracie31 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Ew
- hollerific thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy & Fail
-
- nerdynagy thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy
- agh thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy, Fail & WTF
- mrow! Men's Magazine's "Demean... and thinks it’s Trashy & WTF
- metabolic thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Win
- tiffchin Men's Magazine's "Demean... and thinks it’s OMG
- torsl965 thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is Trashy, Fail & WTF
- Yolie4u thinks Men's Magazine's "Demean... is WTF
-
-
-
FlickMontana 5 months agoThe image is ok, it’s just the use and commentary that’s… ..skwicky
-
-
-
-
-






Special Reactions
Your Reaction?
React with an animated GIF!
READY. SET. REACT!
GET STARTED