I wanna see Calvin and Christopher Robin go at it.

hobbes ftw

Based on this depiction, it's a tough call. Pooh's movement is going to be severely restricted by his immense bulk and tight fitting t-shirt. While Hobbes' agility comes into question when one considers that his anaconda-like tail comprises nearly one quarter of his body mass. But… of we are talking about a match-up involving their original comic presentations… then Hobbes would beat ass six ways to Sunday. He'd stomp a mudhole in Pooh's ass. His flying tackle and ground game are legendary.

We all know Hobbes would win. Think about all the fighting experience he has with Calvin alone. Plus, let's face it, Pooh isn't the most aggressive of creatures.
My money is on the stripey one.

Isn't Hobbes a Tigger?