Just do not line your lower eyelids. Don’t do it. It’s going to be down your cheeks in a couple hours and it makes your eyes look way tiny. And if you think you have small eyes or eyes that are close together, it is well worth it to perfect the winged liner look! I hate most liquid liners but if you find the kind that looks like a felt tip pen/marker, your smooth eyeliner dreams will come true! I always do BB cream, lighter loose powder, fill in brows, then eyes. I use black liquid liner, then press a dark brown shadow right on top of it. This gives me a dark lined look that I love, but softens the edges so I don’t look harsh. Then press the dark brown into the crease, cover the rest of the lid with a subtle shimmery taupe or gold, then dab a lighter shimmer in the inner corner of the eye and right below the brow. Perfect!