The Definitive Ranking Of Coffee-Mate Creamers

Don't make the mistake of buying the wrong creamer again!

1. Hazelnut

momhomeguide.com

The touch of nutty flavor this Coffee-Mate gives to your steamy cup is perfect for daily...or hourly...use. Just unique enough to step above French Vanilla in the polls. It also gets special ranking for cover art, designed by David Bromstad and looking pretty snazzy! Read an awesome interview NellieBellie did with him about this here.

2. French Vanilla

Via coffee-mate.com

This is a classic. While it doesn't particularly stand out, it is a great choice if you are choosing for more than just one person. Everyone will be pleased.

3. Caramel and Coconut

Via coffee-mate.com

The Girl Scouts know delicious; and this creamer is no exception. It is the perfect balance of sweet and interesting.

4. Thin Mint

Via coffee-mate.com

Another Girl Scout winner! This creamer is refreshing. Not a creamer to be used on a daily basis...but definitely flavorful and worthy of space in your refrigerator.

5. Caramel Macchiato

Via coffee-mate.com

Like Vanilla, this is a safe bet for groups. Though it doesn't have a strong, or truly memorable, flavor it is nicely sweet and just a bit rich. The perfect mix for a relaxing cup of joe.

6. Coconut Creme

Via coffee-mate.com

For the coconut lovers out there...this is absolutely the winner! It adds a great sweetness to your morning cup. If you aren't a coconut fan...stay away!

7. Amaretto

Via coffee-mate.com

This creamer gets a middling position because, while it is a tasty option with wonderful nuttiness, very few people feel particularly strongly about it. Yes, it is good. No, it is not often an absolute favorite.

8. Natural Bliss

Via coffee-mate.com

The entire Natural Bliss version receives points for having only ingredients that can be recognized in the bottle. We like knowing what we are drinking! The flavors are lacking a little in "punch" however, lowering the overall ranking of this thoughtful version.

9. Peppermint Mocha

Via coffee-mate.com

Perfect for the holidays. Wonderful for sitting inside on cold, snowy days in the North Country. But... limited in terms of seasonal use. This is not the creamer for your summer.

10. Cafe Mocha

Via coffee-mate.com

This Coffee-Mate ranks lower on the list because it just seems unnecessary. Though it is fairly tasty, it doesn't do anything vanilla creamer and some chocolate syrup couldn't accomplish.

11. Cinnamon Vanilla Creme

Via coffee-mate.com

This is another that goes to the bottom of the list for its lack of purpose. Just buy vanilla, something everyone can enjoy, and add some cinnamon to your own cup of joe.

12. Creme Brulee

Via coffee-mate.com

Why such a low ranking for this tasty cream? It is just too sweet! Some of you may enjoy the sickly sweetness of this particular option...good for you!

13. White Chocolate Caramel Latte

Via coffee-mate.com

This creamer sits lower in ranking because of the redundancy of its name. "White Chocolate" is simply sugar and cream...which all creamers have. "Latte" is simply coffee and milk (though this milk isn't steamed...so this title could be a lie). So really...all this title tells you is that it is caramel and is extra sweet.

14. Italian Sweet Creme

Via coffee-mate.com

Another version that drops to the bottom of the list for being overly sweet. The true coffee drinkers among us just can't handle that much pollution in our perfectly brewed cups of coffee.

David Bromstad with Coffee Mate

Via Coffee Mate

Adorableness.

Which would you vote for?