How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern Jane Austen Heroine
By most accounts, she’s a social climber who uses her relationships to elevate her status. Just like her purported new romance with Kanye West.
Reality shows in the vein of “Keeping Up With the Kardashians” have a lot in common with a Jane Austen novel. They focus on the manners of a privileged set (like the “Real Housewives” or Rachel Zoe), their romantic relationships, their wealth and, sometimes, the decline thereof. One critic at the time called Austen’s “Mansfield Park” “[n]ot much of a novel, more the history of a family party in the country, very natural,” which sounds a lot like a description of a “Real Housewives” episode (minus the natural part). Kim Kardashian’s koncerns (sorry), superficial as they may be, have actually been the stuff of popular entertainment for centuries.
“Sense and Sensibility” and “Pride and Prejudice,” in particular, both feature women who advance themselves by means of men. The Dashwood sisters of the former have to marry well because their father’s money has all gone to their half-brother. And the Bennets have to do so because, as women, they can’t inherit their dad’s estate. Since working is unheard-of in their class, they have to get hitched to maintain their status.
It’s not much different for the world’s most famous reality star. To maintain her position, she has to stay in the public eye by finding new ways to make us care about her. One easy way to do that, since Ms. K has few discernible talents (and has already posed nude and been videotaped having sex), is through her relationships with men — and not just any men. No, she needs to be with guys who will raise her public profile by willingly serving as tabloid fodder and hopefully bringing their own audiences with them.
Lantern-jawed insta-husband Kris Humphries satisfied the former condition (unlike Knicks’ forward Danilo Gallinari, reportedly an early husband candidate who was unwilling to be on TV) but sadly, not the latter. But Kanye West, who Kim’s now allegedly dating (or “seeing where it goes” with) fulfills both criteria admirably — a regular Mr. Darcy.
Of course, Kim Kardashian and Elizabeth Bennet differ quite a bit, and not only in ways involving plastic surgery. Unlike Austen’s heroines, no one really expects Kim to marry someone for love — and audiences probably don’t care if this figures into her romantic exploits or not.
Austen had an idealistic streak, and her sharp female protagonists usually manage to fall deeply for men who just happen to also be able to support them in the style they’re accustomed to. Darcy may be gruff at the beginning of “Pride and Prejudice,” but by the end Elizabeth is crazy about him. At least judging by body language and, well, their divorce, that doesn’t seem to have been true of Kim and Kris. Whether it’s true of Kanye remains to be seen. But previous history suggests that unlike Lizzie Bennet, Kim Kardashian places more value on her own fame than love.
HOT ON
Facebook Conversations
14 Responses So Far
- akatobi2002 thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is LOL
-
- toughlove2 thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Quirky, Fail & LOL
- noodl33333 thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Don't Trust
- perhapsnot thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Don't Trust
-
- bosephine thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Fail
- jannar2 How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... and thinks it’s Get Real & Fail
-
jannar2 a year agoYou seemed to have missed the point of Auten’s work. Austen’s heroines are self-aware or become self-aware. They also did not have the educational and professional opportunities women have today. Try reading a bit more actively next time. If I was your college instructor (or even high school, as your essay is at about that level of comprehension) I’d have to give you a C for this essay. In other words, your argument in invalid.
-
- aaront7 thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Fail & Get Real
- mommy How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J...
-
- How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is starting to get hot on Facebook Share It
- Ladyjenn925 How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... and thinks it’s Fail, Ew & WTF
- Evija Ģ. thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Win
- DerpMerp How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... and thinks it’s Fail
-
DerpMerp a year agoThis article is bullshit. Shift is really joke. Jane Austin’s characters are strong, filled with morality and learn from their mistakes. Kim Kardashian is just some gutter whore prancing around in front of cameras in Hollywood begging for people to give a shit about her. Classic famewhore.
-
- Samantha M. thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Fail
- adinar thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Get Real
- rakl thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Fail
- shimengyund How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J...
- Vixenly thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Get Real, Fail & Trashy
- therblig thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Fail
- vespo How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J...
-
- Dariana thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Don't Trust, Get Real & Fail
-
Dariana a year agoThis article sounds like a drunken truth or dare experiment made over cosmopolitans at a trendy bar in Manhattan. ‘LOL OMG I totally dare you to write an article comparing Jane Austen’s protagonists to Kim Kardashian!’ ‘LOL I’M SO DOING IT!’ Or, worse yet, it looks like someone viewed an undergraduate research paper prompt about connecting 18th century writing to today’s sociocultural practices and came up with this. Or, perhaps worst of all, this actually is an undergraduate research paper that the author found crumpled up on a bus, with a big red F in the corner, and said, ‘Ohh! Cool article for Shift!’
-
-
- Niloufar N. thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is WTF
- KillJoy How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... and thinks it’s LOL, Get Real & Fail
-
lynne benoux a year agoI have nothing to offer other than a gentle push to read the actual novels that were so clumsily insulted.
-
- Alibug thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Don't Trust
- a short haired girl How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... and thinks it’s WTF, Get Real & Fail
- your mom thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Get Real & Fail
- baseballgirl thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Fail, Get Real & Wut
- edgerrton thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Fail, WTF & Get Real
-
- samanthaq2 thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Trashy & Get Real
- shalalalalauooo thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Win
- erina5 thinks How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... is Fail
-
turtlefeed a year agoAlso, Kirstie Alley is just like Dorothy from the Wizard of Oz because both of them are from Kansas, have small dogs, and sought help for personal problems that they eventually overcame.
Never mind that each life (or fictional life, in Dorothy’s case) should be contextualized in terms of its respective culture and historical period to really make sense of their behavior. I mean, if you think about it for too long the comparison seems kind of silly. But that doesn’t matter, right? -
-
Kasey Byrne a year agoIn all of Austen’s novels, the young heroine is smart, morally sound and determined to marry for love, not money. Hence, there is no comparison whatsoever. thankskbyee!
-
- Raccoons How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J... and thinks it’s Don't Trust, Get Real & Fail
-
-
- Lauren Lipsay How Kim Kardashian Is Like A Modern J...








Special Reactions
Your Reaction?
React with an animated GIF!
READY. SET. REACT!
GET STARTED